Results/Conclusions To track the movement patterns of American white pelicans and delineate the provenance of new colonizers, we used microsatellite and mtDNA markers, stable-isotopes, and trace-element analysis to characterize potential source colonies and assign new colonizers to source populations. Blood and tissue samples from 333 nestlings from 19 colonies spanning the continent, from California to Ontario, were used for microsatellite and mtDNA analysis. Our genetic analyses indicated complete panmixia across the entire range of American white pelicans, suggesting low utility of genetic data for tracking movement or assigning colonizers to source populations. Stable-isotope analysis of 221 individuals from 22 colonies spanning the same range as our genetic data indicated a high level of within-colony variation, supporting the idea that low site fidelity and high rates of dispersal likely led to the lack of range-wide genetic differentiation. However, despite high levels of within-site variation, among-site patterns of variation were high enough to allow us to create an isotopic “map” to which we were able to assign new colonizers from two newly established colonies to potential source populations. New colonies of American white pelicans appear to be composed of individuals that molted across a wide range of locations and habitats and these new colonies were not merely assemblages of individuals from nearby colonies. Though a multiple-isotope approach using H, C, and N provided moderate resolution at a broad spatial scale, we also present preliminary evidence that suggests trace-element analysis will provide high resolution at a fine (colony-level) spatial scale.